Quote:
Originally Posted by julf
> Bear in mind the email integration is an added convenience
> designed to help transition people from an old fashioned mail
> list to a relatively richly featured web based forum.
I have to disagree with your description of mail as "old fashioned".
It's like saying "books are old-fashioned, we should all read
newspapers". Both web pages and email have their pros and cons.
|
Quite right - I should have used the term "simple". My aim is to replace the BEEF mail list, which is about as simple as mail lists come.
Quote:
Originally Posted by julf
The only real benefit of a web-based forum is the integration
of pictures and documents, but that is (in my opinion) better
done with a separate wiki site anyway.
|
I can't agree with you there Julf. There are some forums I use a lot which don't allow documents or pictures but are an absolute mine of information -
http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/ is an ideal example.
I don't know much about building wikis. I've looked at a few over recent years - Jot was looking very good before it was acquired by Google, but we're building several sites with vBulletin so it made sense to stick with it. I've had some mods developed which I can use on multiple sites.
To my mind the biggest benefits of a web based discussion forum over a mail list are (a) the permanency of the information, and (b) the fact that the discussion can be split into categories. Also, we have included a separate document repository - the Resources Section.
Quote:
Originally Posted by julf
I know from experience that the extra hassle of a web forum will
make me drop out of the forum eventually - the only discussion
groups I have been following for more than a year or two are
e-mail-based.
|
Each to his own. But at least the information will still be there if you need it later. I know from experience lots of people leave mail lists because they have no way of avoiding all the stuff they are
not interested in. At least with this site people can subscribe to the forums they are interested in and ignore the rest.
Quote:
Originally Posted by julf
(P.S. if you google me you see that I am no Internet luddite, But
my 30 years of using the net in it's different forms has given me
some pretty strong views of what works for me, and what doesn't)
|
I don't think anyone said you were an "Internet Luddite" and I do value your feedback, despite the fact that I might not agree with you
Incidentally, I'm a great fan of email. I've even posted a couple of replies on here from my Blackberry while walking the dog in the park! I also run a business who's life blood is email - we sell employment advertising on targeted, opt-in mail lists!
However, what I'm attempting to do with this site is create something for Bristol enthusiasts which is better than what currently exists, and is not censored. Given that I am a businessman and not a coder I am fairly happy with the result so far.